Menu of Nick Charlap’s Ice Cream in Kenmore, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Nick Charlap’s Ice Cream, nestled in Kenmore, NY, offers a nostalgic yet vibrant experience for ice cream lovers and casual diners alike. Located at 2800 Elmwood Ave, this family-owned gem serves more than just classic scoops — it’s a destination where traditional flavors meet playful twists.

The menu at Nick Charlap’s stands out for its delightful variety. Beyond the expected cold treats, the presence of hot dogs and French fries introduces a well-rounded comfort food option. This mix of savory and sweet makes it a versatile stop whether you crave a quick snack or a full nostalgic meal.

Highlights include the Butterscotch Ice Cream, which delivers a creamy, buttery richness that tastes homemade and satisfying. The Dipped Ice Cream offers a crisp chocolate shell that contrasts beautifully with the smooth interior. The Blackcherry Custard with Cherry Dip strikes a perfect balance between tartness and sweetness, elevating classic custard to an indulgent treat.

The Banana Split remains a crowd-pleaser, artfully combining banana slices with strawberry and vanilla ice cream, topped with luscious syrups and whipped cream — a true homage to old-school dessert bars. For fruit lovers, the Strawberry Dole Cream and Strawberry Ice Cream provide fresh, vibrant flavors that taste bright and natural.

Customer impressions echo the authenticity and quality of Nick Charlap’s offerings. Alyssa Nie mentions returning for the twist cone and strawberry sundae experiences, appreciating the friendly staff and overall flavor, notwithstanding a slight freezer burn incident on one buttercrunch sundae. Meanwhile, Alicia Cercone highlights the rich, indulgent taste of the Peanut Butterfudge and the complex texture of Vanilla with peanut butter swirl and chocolate chip frozen yogurt — both praised as delicious and satisfying.

Overall, Nick Charlap’s Ice Cream is more than just an ice cream parlor; it’s a place where tradition meets warmth in every scoop and bite. Whether you’re drawn by their standout custards, classic sundaes, or even their savory snacks, this spot promises a comforting, enjoyable experience for the whole family.